Lincoln did not need to hold them against there will that was just irresponsible and we lost a lot of people, goods, houses, ammo, weapons, good, and soldiers. Heres a map of the united states voting results, county by county, from the 2012 elections. If the south had been allowed to secede, both north and south could have benefited. Our cheap essay writing service why did the south secede from the union essay tries to always be at its best performance level, so each customer who pays money for paper writing can be sure that he or she will get what is wanted. A northern manifesto for southern secession argued that both the united states and the south might both be best served if southern. The south is not going to secede and if the south did secede it would not be good for the country in general. Namely, when the confederacy seceded from the union in the wake of the 1860 election, did they have the. The comments that have been generated by this post at my personal blog on leejackson day, as well as a comment thread ive been involved with in response to a related post at republitarian, have led me to an interesting question. High tariffs had prompted the nullification controversy in 1833, when, after south carolina demanded the right to nullify federal laws or secede in. Discussion in politics started by dave nocal, feb 3, 2010. Two boys are rolling rubber tires down the cobblestoned. The power of this country and the prosperity we have enjoyed is directly related to our unity, resource distribution, capability by region.
Five myths about why the south seceded washington post. Recently were seeing the secession petitions, and lincoln is on at the movies. Conflict and disagreement grew and grew until eventually it was too much to handle. Thompson is unable to find a single positive thing about the south in his hundreds of pages of interviews and visits, so this book only serves to alienate the southern half of the audience. The differences between the two regions were plentiful, and the similarities were slim. We are a group of world citizens who believe encouraging the former south territories to form a seperate political. Except for south carolina the states that seceded did so by using political dirty tricks.
The two major sections of the nation came to the realization that a coexistence which had become laborious and conflictive was an impossible task. The gold and silver of europe will come to buy southern cotton and the ships of europe will come to carry it away, even if lincoln should be elected, and we should secede. This includes all military equipment at fort hood and any other military establishment in. Secessionists push for south to break away from us again. The north would have evolved into a country with social and economic policies similar to those of canada or northern european countries without the continuing drag of a large undeveloped and inefficient south. They also seceded because the north was fighting for justice and peace and wanted to free the slaves, and the south did not want to get rid of their slaves. Last year, it boasted six of the top eight states in terms of net domestic migration texas.
Feb 03, 2010 as far as im concerned the south can secede and we wouldnt miss them. Most of the states which receive more money than they contribute are in the south. Sep 21, 2012 doktor zooms real name is marty kelley, and he lives in the wilds of boise, idaho. The south needed to secede before the north amended the constitution. The force of events moved very quickly upon the election of lincoln. The decision to secede and establish the confederacy. Trouble might arise if a state decided to secede without an overwhelming majority.
Once the secession is complete, washington should begin removing all of the u. Second, if lincoln had allowed the south to secede, i doubt it would have lasted long enough to be an ally of hitler. The fight would start in the federal courts and could get very ugly. The 5149 split each year between red and blue states makes me wonder when the great repressive dictatorship of flyover country, the left coast democratic state, the northeast libertarian union and state, and the southeast theocracy will each form. The news that thousands of people have signed a petition for their own states to secede from the union has raised this issue once again. Please do show me where you found that in the rule book.
The civil war was by far the most catastrophic event to ever happen in the american south. How anyone can claim that the south was vindicated in its actions is beyond me. Feb 14, 2009 the south is not going to secede and if the south did secede it would not be good for the country in general. Only a tiny amount of the conservatives want to secede from the union. South carolina acted first, calling for a convention to secede from the union. The confederate states of america would no more tolerate a federal fort within their borders than the colonials would have tolerated a british fort in boston or new york harbor, and to these advisers it wasnt worth going to war over. Civil war awakening is adam goodhearts contribution to the canon of civil war historiography. One of them was because a line in the declaration of independence offended a senator from south carolina, therefore, he. Everyone interested in the overall design of the constitution ratified by the several states in 1788 should read this book. People in the south have a very different idea of governance than those in the north. Whether you believe in it or not, it is the title of a book. However actions taken to enforce the undetermined right to secede were illegal. The south said they had the right, the north said they did not.
Im not a constitutional scholar but i dont believe that the subject of leaving the union is addressed there. The government of south carolina declared its causes for seceding on december 24, 1860, four days after it became the first state to issue a formal ordinance of secession on december 20, 1860. Its ironic to me that that portion of the population that claims to be the most patriotic was the first to talk about seceding after obama got elected. The south was weak, both militarily and economically. It also shows how the south should have had the right to decide whether they would want to secede from the country or not. Lincoln had been advised by his top military commander, general winfield scott, and most of his cabinet, to abandon fort sumter. Well leave to another time the suspicioninducing question of why so much attention is focused on the most extreme remedy for federal overreaching when the framers own perfectly constitutional remedy remains neglected the state application and. So serious in fact, that he wrote a book called better off without em.
Alabamabased southern nationalists again calling for south. We would have avoided a lot of problems, thompson said. There have been at least a few discussions on whether abraham lincoln and the republicans should have prosecuted the civil war, but surprisingly very little analysis on whether south carolinas secession in 1860 was a strategically wise move in the. The south did not have the legal right to leave the union.
There was no affirmative law, court decision or constitutional provision at either the federal or state level making secession legal. Yes, texas should be allowed to secede from the union. The south was willing to rip apart the country to save its means of economic prosperity by the inhuman and unchristian institution of slavery. The south still attracts the most domestic migrants of any u. The fact that both states went for obama in 2008 should refute the idea of a solid south in a redblue dichotomous nation. One of them was because a line in the declaration of independence offended a senator from south carolina, therefore, he threatened to secede. The civil war awakening also has the latter word in its title because of the fact that goodheart focuses much on the social and ideological awakenings that the war came to entail. If a state seceded based on a 23rds majority, or worse, a 23rds legislative vote, i could see the federal government stepping in to stop it. Yes, the us should have let the seven initially seceding states leave. Ive been the subject of vandalism, i wouldnt stick around to find out if our local government was ok with taking it to the next level.
South should secede and create a new antigay country called reagan. Jan 31, 20 the south still attracts the most domestic migrants of any u. I wont see lincoln until its out on dvd, but tonight i watched the miniseries based on gore vidals book. The south was right james ronald kennedy, walter donald. These states contained a high population of slaves and slave owners believed their. Seven states passed secession ordinances in 1860 and 61, and four of them sent representatives to other slave states, explaining the reasons why they too should secede. The best that can be said is that the right of secession was undetermined. Why did south carolina and the deep south secede from the union.
When did south carolina secede from the union answers. Doktor zooms real name is marty kelley, and he lives in the wilds of boise, idaho. There are a few pockets in the south that have value, but the most of it is just a cesspool of racism, ignorance and welfare. As i write this, the streets outside my hotel are very quiet. Lee siegel on why the south should get the hell out of the union. Civil war scholar shelby foote i think put it best the southern states would never have joined the union if they thought they couldnt. The book is unique in that it is focused on the titular year, give or take a few for historical context. Within three months of lincolns election, seven states had seceded from the union. The prospect of a federal government controlled by the black republican party was too much for some, and south carolina was the first state to secede, followed quickly by six others. The south is not a perfect place, but neither is the north, and painting one side as fully negative in every possible way does not present a balanced argument. New york should secede from the union june 23, 1975. State by state, conventions were held, and the confederacy was formed. I, for one, believe that lincoln did what was necessary to save the country. Last year, it boasted six of the top eight states in terms of net domestic migration texas, florida, north carolina.
What would happen if the south seceded from the us today. Albert taylor bledsoe, author, brion mcclanahan and mike church, editors published a year after the war, it provides the best argument every assembled in one book for the constitutional right of secession. Essay why south secede 1861 sources a boles j 1995 the. Oct 16, 2017 a trial there would have given africanamericans one of the first opportunities to serve on a jury. I would leave the south if this happened as my political views are not accepted. The author of a new book challenges northerners and southerners to consider the possibility of a friendly divorce. Aug 09, 2012 is it finally time to let the south secede. In the momentous step which our state has taken of dissolving its connection with the government of which we so long formed a part, it is but just that we should declare the prominent reasons which have induced our course. Should the south be permitted and encouraged to secede from. This did not necessarily have to mean civil war, but few in the north were prepared to readily see the union dismembered.
Some white southerners are again advocating for what the confederacy tried and. As the first state to secede, south carolinas declarations established precedent and unabashedly claimed that the primary reason for secession remained the refusal of northern states to comply with the fugitive slave act and the dred scott 1857 decision. Lincoln should have allowed the south to secede institute. Apr 07, 2018 did the south, in light of their grievances, have the right to secede. From the moment the head start program first helped poor blacks form their own preschools in mississippi, the south declared war against the war against poverty. Aug 12, 2012 frankly, the south is a drain on the economy and provides nothing to the nation other than backwards thinking and idiotic politicans. Author advocates letting mouthbreathing, racist south. The original document is housed in the south carolina department of archives and history, columbia, south carolina. South carolina and the deep south were the first seven states to secede from the union in 1860 to early 1861. If lincoln had allowed the south to peacefully secede.
The most common belief is that the american civil war was a war about slaves. The south shouldnt secede, they should just simply sell the north to canada, go mooch off of them for awhile. Over one hundred thirty years ago the southern states seceded from the federal union. Alabamabased southern nationalists again calling for. The south is the reason the united states has one of the lowest levels of social spending in the world. The north would have evolved into a country with social and economic policies similar to those of canada or northern european countries without the continuing drag of a. Or that the average juror wouldnt be convinced that secession was legal. A declaration of the immediate causes which induce and justify the secession of the state of mississippi from the federal union.
The south seceded because they knew they did not want to abide by the union laws about slavery so they separated the south seceded because of tariffs. Letting the south secede would have benefited both the south and the union. Ive been the subject of vandalism, i wouldnt stick around to find out if our local. There have been at least a few discussions on whether abraham lincoln and the republicans should have prosecuted the civil war, but surprisingly very little analysis on whether south carolinas secession in 1860 was a strategically wise move in the context of the american debate on. The south after much deliberation decided to secede. The secessionist state governments were not popular. In reality, the south did want to become a separate entity. He promoted it in a recent radio interview with alternets joshua holland. A northern manifesto for southern secession argued that both the united states and the south might both be best served if southern nationalists won. Essay why south secede 1861 sources a boles j 1995 the south. We should have let the south secede from the union. Author advocates letting mouthbreathing, racist south secede. The north would not fair well without the south, nor would the south fair well without the north.
Lincoln should have let them go because that just caused a huge war and what is the point of our union if it was people unwillingly in it. The south wanted to keep their slaves, fear of race mixing, and southerners believed that the northerners were overstepping their boundaries. The book also claims that three statesvirginia, maryland, and rhode islandreserved in their actions of ratification their right to secede from the union. You should definitely donate some money to this little mommyblog where he has finally found acceptance and cat pictures. By jay reeves associated press, august 12, 2017, 3. Frankly, the south is a drain on the economy and provides nothing to the nation other than backwards thinking and idiotic politicans. Jul 16, 20 i picked up this book though for 4 reasons. If the south had been allowed to secede, probably the north and the south would have stayed neutral in wwi to avoid entering on opposite sides in that war.
Did the south, in light of their grievances, have the right to secede. On the off chance that you dont like your order, you can request a refund and we will return the money according to our moneyback guarantee. In late 1860 and early 1861, stateappointed commissioners traveled the length and breadth of the slave south carrying a fervent message in pursuit of a clear goal. A trial there would have given africanamericans one of the first opportunities to serve on a jury. He is not a medical doctor, but does have a real phd in rhetoric. Another example is that when the southern states joined the union, it was voluntarily appleby et.
236 666 304 600 1186 1261 454 691 47 1283 1024 1449 1323 373 428 8 1147 1095 1298 387 378 270 1222 779 1157 931 531 1486 1175 155